Tasting Fee: $20.00 (Tasting includes 7 wines)
4.8 (74) Google Reservations Recommended
Notes are saved automatically as you type

Rolling Bay Winery on Bainbridge Island offers a unique wine experience with grapes from some of Washington's oldest vines, planted in 1979. This family-owned winery is a hidden gem, providing a personal touch with opportunities for private barrel tastings for wine club members. Enjoy small-batch, hand-crafted wines in a scenic outdoor setting, just a short ferry ride from Seattle. The winery's focus on quality over quantity ensures a memorable visit for wine enthusiasts seeking distinctive flavors and intimate experiences.

6.0

PourPlan Rating How it works

Research-based analysis of public-facing information
Research-Based Analysis

4
Tasting Fee (20%)
high confidence

$20 tasting fee with no waiver or refund option - you'll pay this regardless of whether you purchase wine.

N/A
Wine Value (20%)

None

9
Hospitality (15%)
high confidence

Consistently praised for friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable staff; only one negative review among overwhelmingly positive feedback.

6
Wine (15%)
low confidence

No professional ratings available. Public sentiment suggests satisfactory quality, but without verified ratings, the score remains conservative.

8
Vibe (15%)
medium confidence

Described as cozy, inviting, and authentic; one negative mention but generally positive atmosphere comments.

5
Setting (10%)
high confidence

The photo shows a simple red barn structure with some outdoor seating. The grounds appear to be somewhat maintained, but the setting lacks distinctive architecture or landscaping. The presence of trees adds some natural appeal, but overall, the setting is modest and functional rather than aesthetically remarkable.

N/A
Parking (5%)

None

This rating synthesizes public-facing information including the winery's website, hours, fees, and wine portfolio. We plan to visit in person to provide additional firsthand perspective.

Wines at a Glance

Red dominant
Red Wines
Cabernet Franc (1) Cabernet Sauvignon (2) Grenache (1) Malbec (1) Red Blend (5) Syrah (1) Tempranillo (2)
Rosé Wines
Grenache (1)
White Wines
Chardonnay (2) Pinot Gris (1)

Pricing Overview

Mid-range reds dominate, with standout premium options across all types.

What Makes This Place Special

Family-Owned
The inviting winemaker and staff are willing to share the wonders of winemaking with visitors, creating a personal, family-like atmosphere.
Hidden Gem
Located on beautiful Bainbridge Island, just a short ferry ride from Seattle, offering a unique wine experience away from the mainstream.
Historic Location
Many of their varietals come from grapes planted in 1979, which are some of the oldest vines in Washington State, giving their wines more structure and complex flavors.
Outdoor Seating
Confirmed during in-person visit
Private Tastings
Wine club members at Premiere and Platinum levels receive private barrel tastings with the winemaker for up to 6-8 people after their first year of membership.
Scenic Views
Visitors can enjoy the beautiful scenery of Bainbridge Island while sipping wine at their outdoor tables.
Small Batch
Specializes in creating limited quantities of hand-crafted premium wines, focusing on quality over quantity.
Wine Club
Multiple membership options available including Signature, Premiere, and Platinum clubs, each offering different benefits and customizable wine selections.